Over the next forty-eight hours, the security app on my backup iPhone became my favorite television show. The footage collected over the weekend was nothing short of a masterclass in entitlement.
Saturday night: Kyle let himself in at 1:30 AM, heavily intoxicated, carrying a box of leftover pizza that he proceeded to drop grease stains all over our white kitchen chairs.
Sunday morning: Kyle woke up around 11:00 AM, walked out of Chloe’s bedroom wearing only boxers, poured himself a cup of my gourmet organic coffee beans using our French press, and left the wet grounds caked inside the glass cylinder to mold.
Sunday afternoon: He invited two of his fraternity brothers over while Chloe wasn't even home, raiding our refrigerator for string cheese and soda, and leaving their muddy gym shoes right in the middle of the hallway floor.
I downloaded every single video clip, saving them into a secure folder titled *Evidence*, complete with timestamps and brief descriptions of the lease violations.
Sarah joined me at the kitchen island on Sunday evening to review the highlight reel. We watched the footage on my laptop with the sound turned down low, her jaw dropping lower with every passing second.
Keep the story going
Watch a short ad to unlock the rest of this chapter.
"He's using my shampoo?" Sarah whispered in disbelief as she watched Kyle casually pocket her expensive skincare cleanser from the bathroom shelf. "That bottle cost thirty-five dollars!"
"He's also storing his extra sneakers in our hall closet," I replied, clicking to the next video clip. "And look at this one—he's using our dish towels to wipe down his sweaty gym equipment."
Sarah let out a harsh, bitter laugh. "I'm done being nice. I don't care if Chloe cries. I don't care if she stops talking to us for the rest of the semester. This is literally trespassing and petty theft."
"It's worse than that," I said, leaning back in my chair. "Under our lease, unauthorized occupancy is grounds for immediate lease termination for the primary tenant—which means Chloe could technically get us all evicted if management finds out she gave him an unauthorized key."
Sarah went pale. "Wait. If management finds out, we *all* get kicked out?"
"Not if we handle it smartly," I replied, a small smile forming on my lips. "We don't go to management as victims begging for help. We go to management with airtight proof, requesting a formal warning and lock replacement for safety reasons, while forcing Chloe to choose between her lease or her freeloader boyfriend."
Our plan was simple, ruthless, and entirely legal.
On Monday morning, Chloe had an early shift at her internship followed by evening classes. She wouldn't be back until 9:00 PM. Kyle, according to his gym schedule visible on his public social media, usually hit the campus weight room around 2:00 PM every Monday.
That left a four-hour window where the apartment would be completely empty of them—and fully stocked with all the evidence we needed.
I printed out a formal, typed letter addressed to Mr. Henderson, attaching stills from the security footage showing Kyle entering the apartment without Chloe present, stealing toiletries, and using our kitchen facilities without authorization.
The trap was fully baited. All we had to do was spring it.