The smell of cheap garlic powder and burning cheap olive oil hit me the second I unlocked the apartment door. It was 7:15 PM on a Tuesday. I had spent eight hours at my internship downtown, lugging a heavy laptop bag across three subway transfers, and all I wanted was to drop my bag on the couch and microwave the leftover chicken breast I had carefully portioned out the night before.
Instead, the stove was occupied.
A tall, broad-shouldered guy in gray sweatpants and a backwards baseball cap was standing over my non-stick pan—the one I got for my twentieth birthday and explicitly banned everyone from using with metal utensils—scraping eggs with a stainless-steel fork.
"Hey," I said, dropping my keys into the bowl by the door. My voice was dangerously flat. "Who said you could use that pan?"
The guy jumped, nearly dropping the spatula. He turned around, flashing a breezy, infuriatingly casual grin that I had grown to loathe over the past three months. It was Kyle. Chloe’s boyfriend. The guy who lived in apartment 4B, exactly two floors above us, but somehow spent ninety percent of his waking—and sleeping—hours squatting in 25.
"Oh, hey Maya! You're back early," Kyle said, treating my kitchen like he was the host of a cooking show and I was an unexpected studio audience member. "Chloe said it was cool. I was craving a late protein snack before the gym."
"Chloe is currently working a double shift at the restaurant downtown," I replied, crossing my arms over my chest. "She is not here. Which means you are here alone. Again."
Kyle shrugged, turning back to the stove to flip his pathetic-looking eggs. "So? I have a key now. Chloe made me a copy last week so I could let in the cable guy. Big deal."
Keep the story going
Watch a short ad to unlock the rest of this chapter.
That single sentence made my blood pressure spike to numbers dangerous for a twenty-year-old. Chloe made him a copy. Without asking me. Without asking Sarah, our third roommate, who was currently locked in her bedroom studying for a brutal organic chemistry midterm.
"You are not on the lease, Kyle," I said, stepping closer to the kitchen island. "And this is not your apartment. You have your own place upstairs. Why are you constantly cooking, eating, and sleeping down here?"
"My kitchen is messy," he mumbled, scraping the scrambled eggs onto one of my ceramic dinner plates—plates I bought with my own hard-earned babysitting money. "And besides, you guys have better spices."
He didn't even say thank you. He just picked up my plate, grabbed a fork from the drawer without washing his hands first, and sauntered over to the living room couch like he owned the building. He didn't bother taking off his sneakers, leaving muddy November sludge right on the edge of our entryway rug.
I stood in the center of the kitchen, staring at the grease splatters across the stove I had spent two hours cleaning just the day before. The sponge was still damp on the counter. The dish-drying rack was still slightly askew where I had left it to air dry.
This wasn't just about eggs or a messy stove. This was about entitlement. This was about a guy who treated our home like a free hotel, complete with maid service and a stocked pantry.
Sarah's bedroom door cracked open an inch. Her tired, stressed eyes peeked out. "Is he still here?" she whispered.
"Yeah," I whispered back, my jaw aching from how hard I was clenching my teeth. "And he's eating off my plates."
Sarah sighed, a long, defeated sound that broke my heart a little. "I can't take this anymore, Maya. We need to do something. If you don't set a hard boundary tonight, I'm going to lose my mind."
I looked over at Kyle, who had propped his muddy sneakers right up on our coffee table and was scrolling loudly through TikTok with the volume turned all the way up. A cold resolve settled in my chest. I had tried being polite. I had tried dropping hints.
Those days were officially over.
"Don't worry, Sarah," I said loud enough for Kyle to hear over his phone speaker. "Things are about to change around here."